바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

logo

  • P-ISSN0023-3900
  • E-ISSN2733-9343

Prioritizing the Ruler-Subject Relationship: How the Yeonam Group Viewed the Han Chinese under Qing China

Korea Journal, (P)0023-3900; (E)2733-9343
2018, v.58 no.3, pp.128-155
https://doi.org/10.25024/kj.2018.58.3.128

  • Downloaded
  • Viewed

Abstract

This paper will show how the Yeonam Group’s perception of the Han Chinese influenced the development of Northern Learning. Previous studies have noted this influence but did not adequately examine its cause. Conservative intellectuals in Joseon regarded the Qing and its subjects as barbaric, even repugnant. The queue hairstyle which the Qing insisted every adult male wear became a focal point for this disdain. The Yeonam Group also made the queue a focal point, but rather than seeing it as shameful, they tried to view it as an indication that the Han Chinese were acting in accordance with Confucian virtues, foremost of which was the loyalty a subject owed his sovereign. The Yeonam Group believed the Qing to be a worthy inheritor of the Mandate of Heaven and that the queue could be seen as a legitimate institution of the new dynasty. This belief did not cause them to abandon the Ming. By focusing on loyalty, the Yeonam Group found a Confucian virtue that allowed them to accept the advances made by the Qing without forsaking their fidelity to the Ming.

keywords
Joseon Yeonam Group Northern Learning Han Chinese Ming loyalism Mandate of Heaven

Reference

1.

Bak, Je-ga. [1778] 2013. Bukhagui (Theory of Northern Learning). Translated by An Dae-hoe. Seoul: Dolbegae.

2.

Bak, Ji-won. [1932] 2000. Yeonamjip (Collected Works of Yeonam Bak Ji-won). Vol. 252 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

3.

Bak, Jong-chae. [1826] 1997. Gwajeongnok (Memories of My Father, Bak Ji-won). Translated by Kim Yun-jo. Seoul: Taehaksa.

4.

Confucius, and James Legge. 1971. Confucius: Confucian Analects, the Great Learning, and the Doctrine of the Mean. New York: Dover Publications.

5.

Dong, Zhongshu. [n.d.] 2016. Luxuriant Gems of the Spring and Autumn. Edited and translated by Sarah A. Queen and John S. Major. New York: Columbia University Press.

6.

Fang, Xiaoru. [1561] 1983. Xunzhizhaiji (Collected Works of Xunzhizhai Fang Xiaoru). Taipei: Taiwan shangwu yinshu guan.

7.

Han, Won-jin. [n.d.] 1998. Namdangjip (Collected Works of Namdang Han Wonjin). Vol. 201 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

8.

Hong, Dae-yong. [1939] 2000. Damheonseo (Collected Works of Damheon Hong Dae-yong). Vol. 248 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

9.

Hong, Hui-jun. n.d. Jeon-gu (Collected Works of Hong Hui-jun), vol. 4. Request No. 342B-290. Seoul: Kyujanggak Institute for Korean Studies, Seoul National University.

10.

Kim, Chang-heup. [1753] 1996. Samyeonjip (Collected Works of Samyeon Kim Chang-heup). Vol. 167 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

11.

Seong, Dae-jung. [n.d.] 2006. Gugyeok cheongseong japgi (Korean Translation of Miscellaneous Records of Cheongseong Seong Dae-jung). Translated by Kim Jong-tae et al. Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

12.

Seong, Hae-eung. [1840] 2001. Yeongyeongjae jeonjip (Complete Works of Yeongyeongjae Seong Hae-ung). Vol. 274 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

13.

Yi, Deok-mu. [1796] 1979. Ganbon ajeong yugo (Collected Works of Ajeong Yi Deokmu). Vol. 4 of Gugyeok Cheongjanggwan jeonseo (Korean Translation of the Complete Works of Cheongjanggwan Yi Deok-mu). Translated by Baek-hyo Seong. Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

14.

Yi, Deok-mu. [1809–1810] 2000. Cheongjanggwan jeonseo (Complete Works of Cheongjanggwan Yi Deok-mu). Vol. 258 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

15.

Yi, Hui-gyeong. [1805] 2011. Seolsu oesa (Seolsu Yi Hui-gyeong’s Miscellaneous Notes). Translated by Jaegyo Jin. Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University Press.

16.

Yi, Seo-gu. [n.d.] 2001. Cheokjaejip (Collected Works of Cheokjae Yi Seo-gu). Vol. 270 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

17.

Yu, Deuk-gong. [1801] 1982. Yeondae jaeyurok (Record of Yu Deuk-gong’s Second Trip to Yanjing). Vol. 7 of Gugyeok yeonhaengnok seonjip (Anthology of Beijing Travelogues in Korean). Translated by Sin Ho-yeol. Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

18.

Yu, Seong-nyong. [1633] 1990. Seoaejip (Collected Works of Seoae Yu Seong-nyong). Vol. 52 of Hanguk munjip chonggan (Comprehensive Edition of Korean Literary Collections). Seoul: Minjok Munhwa Chujinhoe.

19.

Zhu, Xi. [1189] 1990. Noneo jipju (Confucian Analects Annotated by Zhu Xi). In Saseo jipju (Annotation of the Four Books). Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University Press.

20.

Zhu, Xi. [1270] 1986. Zhuzi yulei (Topically Arranged Conversations of Master Zhu). Edited by Li Jingde. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.

21.

Bae, Woo-sung. 2012. “Joseon hugi junghwa insik-ui jirijeok maengnak”(Geographical Context of the Perception of Sinocentrism during Late Joseon Period). Hanguksa yeongu (Journal of Korean History) 15: 159–195.

22.

Chan, Wing-ming. 2000. “The Early-Qing Discourse on Loyalty.” East Asian History 19: 27–52.

23.

Chan, Wing-ming. 2011. Qing Dai Qianqi De Zhengzhi Rentong Yu Lishi Shuxie (Political Awareness and Historical Narrative during the Early Qing Period). Shanghai:Shanghai Guji Chubanshe Publishing House.

24.

Chin, Jae-gyo. 1999. Ilgye Hong Yang-ho munhak yeongu (A Study of Ilgye Hong Yang-ho’s Literature). Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University.

25.

Cho, Sung-eul. 1987. “Joseon hugi sahaksa yeongu hyeonhwang” (State of the Field:Late Joseon Historiography). In Hanguk jungse sahoe haechegi-ui jemunje (Problems in the Time of the Disintegration of Korean Medieval Society), edited by Geundaesa Yeonguhoe (Korean Modern History Research Society), 275–310. Seoul: Hanul.

26.

Cho, Sung-san. 2009. “Joseon hugi sorongye-ui godaesa yeongu-wa junghwajuui-ui byeonyong” (Modified Sino-Centralism: The Soron School’s Studies of Ancient History). Yeoksa hakbo (Korean Historical Review) 202: 49–90.

27.

Cho, Sung-san. 2014. “Sippalsegi huban Yi Hui-gyeong Bak Je-ga-ui bukhak sasang nolliwa gohak” (Yi Hui-gyeong and Bak Je-ga’s Discourse on Northern Learning and Ancient Learning in the Late Eighteenth Century). Yeoksa gyoyuk (Korean History Education Review) 130: 83–117.

28.

Cho, Sung-san. 2015. “The Yeonam Group’s Anthologies of Korean Literature Written in Classical Chinese and Adherence to the Chinese Civilization in the Mid-18th and Early 19th Centuries.” Korea Journal 55-3: 30–55.

29.

Cho, Sung-san. 2016. “Yeonam geurup-ui ijeok nonui-wa Chunchu” (Perspectives on the Barbarian: the Yeonam Group’s Discourse and the Chunqiu). Hanguksa yeongu (Journal of Korean History) 172: 223–263.

30.

Choi, Gap-soon. 1978. “Isinjeon pyeonchan simal-gwa geu baegyeong” (On the Background to the Compilation of Erchen zhuan). Cheongju yeoja sabeom daehak nonmunjip (Collection of Essays from Cheongju Women’s Teacher’s College) 7: 37–48.

31.

Haboush, JaHyun Kim. 2005. “Contesting Chinese Time, Nationalizing Temporal Space: Temporal Inscription in Late Joseon Korea.” In Time, Temporality, and Imperial Transition: East Asia from Ming to Qing, edited by Lynn A. Struve, 115–141. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press.

32.

Huh, Tae-yong. 2006. “Bukhak sasang-eul yeongu-haneun sigak-ui jeongae-wa jaegeomto” (Critical Review of Research on Northern Learning). Oneul-ui dongyang sasang (Today’s East-Asian Philosophy) 14: 315–354.

33.

Jung, Ok-ja. 1998. Joseon hugi joseon junghwa sasang yeongu (A Study on the Joseon Sinocentrism in the Late Joseon Period). Seoul: Iljisa.

34.

Karlsson, Anders. 2010. “Geography and Civilization: Chŏng Yagyong and Late Chosŏn Notions of Chunghwa.” Dasanhak (Dasan Learning) 16: 103–120.

35.

Kim, Dae-joong. 2013. “‘Naebu ⇄ oebu’-e daehan du gae-ui siseon-Yi Deukmu-wa Bak je-ga” (Two Perspectives on the Relationship between Joseon and China, Focusing on the Case of Yi Deuk-mu and Bak Je-ga). Hanguksa yeongu (Journal of Korean History) 162: 165–209.

36.

Kim, Yang-seop. 2004. “Wonmal myeongcho geumhwa hakpa-ui jeongtong gwannyeom” (Recognition of Orthodoxy by the Jinhua School in the Late Yuan and Early Ming). Chung-ang saron (Journal of Chung-Ang Historical Studies)20: 102–141.

37.

Kuhn, Philip A. 1990. Soulstealers: The Chinese Sorcery Scare of 1768. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

38.

Langlois, John D., Jr. 1980. “Chinese Culturalism and the Yuan Analogy: Seventeenth-Century Perspective.” Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 40.2: 355–398.

39.

Lee, Hyun-sik. 2008. “Yeolha ilgi-ui ‘Hwangseonggi’ Cheong wangjo jeontongnon” (A Study of the “Record of the Qing Dynasty Capital” in the Yeolha ilgi of Yeonam Bak Ji-won). Gugeo gungmunhak (Korean Language and Literature) 152: 345–359.

40.

Oh, Soo-kyung. 2003. Yeonam geurup yeongu (Study of the Yeonam Group). Seoul:Hanbit.

41.

Park, Hee-byoung. 2013. Beomae-wa pyeongdeung (Philanthropy and Equality). Seoul: Dolbegae.

42.

Park, Su-mil. 2011. “Joseon hugi daeCheong uisik-gwa munhwa suyong” (Attitude of the Intellectual against the Qing Dynasty and the Theory of Receiving Its Culture in the Late Joseon Era). Hanguk hanmunhak yeongu (Journal of Korean Literature in Classical Chinese) 47: 139–172.

43.

Poo, Mu-chou. 2005. Enemies of Civilization: Attitudes toward Foreigners in Ancient Mesopotamia, Egypt, and China. Albany: State University of New York Press.

44.

Qiu, Wenhao. 2012. “Qing chu zhong jun guan” (Regarding the Subject’s Loyalty to the Sovereign during the Early Qing Dynasty). Lishi jiaoyu (History Education)19: 163–184.

45.

Son, Hye-ri. 2014. “Sippal segi huban sipgu segi jeonban joseon jisigin-ui Myeong yumin-e daehan girok-gwa pyeonchan uisik” (Consciousness of Records and Compilation of Joseon Intellectuals on Ming Remnants in the Late Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries). Hanguk silhak yeongu (Korean Silhak Review)28: 327–361.

46.

Woo, Kyung-sup. 2012. “Joseon hugi gwihwa hanin-gwa hwangjo yumin uisik”(Understanding Naturalized Han Chinese and Ming Remnants during the Late Joseon Period). Hangukhak yeongu (Research on Korean Studies) 27: 333–365.

47.

Yoo, Bong-hak. 1995. Yeonam ilpa bukhak sasang yeongu (A Study of the Yeonam Group’s Northern Learning Thought). Seoul: Ilji.

Korea Journal