바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

logo

  • P-ISSN0023-3900
  • E-ISSN2733-9343

Legacies of Japanese Colonialist Historiography and Scholarly Views on Wiman Joseon

Korea Journal, (P)0023-3900; (E)2733-9343
2016, v.56 no.1, pp.93-115
https://doi.org/10.25024/kj.2016.56.1.93

  • Downloaded
  • Viewed

Abstract

This paper seeks to understand how the diverse historical views on Wiman Joseon were formed and evolved, as well as what caused these changes in perspective. In particular, it focuses on how conceptions of Wiman Joseon influenced research and the interpretation of archeological materials following the establishment of modern historical studies. The traditional understanding of Wiman Joseon in early Korean history changed with the emergence of the modern Korean nation from the late nineteenth century, while the modern concept of colony was applied to Wiman Joseon by Japanese scholars starting from the Japanese colonial period (1910–1945). The understanding of the archeological culture of Wiman Joseon was not established independently, but was a by-product of research on the Lelang Commandery. Based on such research, the governing structure of Lelang Commandery was interpreted as a so-called “dualistic ethnic governance structure.” It is important to reflect on whether the modern attempt to establish the state character of Wiman Joseon through the analysis of the ethnicity of Wiman and Wiman Joseon’s ruling class has still failed to emerge from out the shadow of nationalistic and colonialist perceptions.

keywords
Wiman Joseon Lelang Commandery colonial historiography colony dualistic ethnic governance structure Han Chinese culture slender bronze dagger culture

Reference

1.

Barnes, Gina L. 2001. State Formation in Korea: Historical and Archaeological Perspectives. Richmond: Curzon.

2.

Cho, Bup-jong. 2011. “Singminjuuijeok Gojoseonsa insik-ui bipan-gwa gwaje” (Critical Examination of Japanese Colonial History of Gojoseon and Its Tasks). Hanguk godaesa yeongu (Journal of Korean Ancient History) 61: 45–73.

3.

Choi, Mong-ryong. 1985. “Godae gukga seongjang-gwa muyeok” (Development of Ancient State and Trade—The Case of Wiman Joseon). Hanguk godae-ui gukga-wa sahoe (State and Society in Ancient Korea). Seoul: Ilchokak.

4.

Do, Myeon-hoi. 2008. “Hanguk geundae yeoksahak-ui changchul-gwa tongsa chegye-ui hwangnip” (Creation of Korean Modern Historiography and the Establishment of the System of Linear History in Korea). Yeoksa-wa hyeonsil (History and Reality) 70: 171 –206.

5.

Finley, Moses I. 1976. “Colonies—An Attempt at a Typology.” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society (5th Series) 26: 167–188.

6.

Fujita, Ryosaku. 1941. “Koukogakuzou yorimitaru mansenkankei 考古學上より見た る滿鮮關係” (Archeological View of Relations between Manchuria and Joseon). 朝鮮 Chōsen (Korea) 313: 23–31. Seoul: Government-General of Korea.

7.

Fujita, Ryosaku. 1948. Chosen kokogaku kenkyu (A Study of Korean Archeology). Kyoto: Takagiri shoin.

8.

Fujita, Ryosaku and Umehara Sueji. 1947. Chōsen kobunka sokan (Compendium of Ancient Korean Culture). Vol. 1. Tanba: Yotokusha.

9.

Gardiner, Kenneth H. J. 1969. The Early History of Korea. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.

10.

Hayashi, Taitsuke. 1892. Chōsenshi (History of Korea). Tokyo: Yoshikawa kobunkan.

11.

Imanishi, Ryu. 1935. “Chosen no Bunka-Koenshuki” (Culture of Korea—Lecture Notes). Chosenshi no shiori (Introduction to the History of Korea). Keijo: Chikazawa shoten.

12.

Inaba, Iwakichi. 1915. Manshu hattatsushi (Manchuria Development History). Tokyo: Osakayago shoten.

13.

Jo, Jin-seon. 2005. “Bukhan jiyeok sehyeong donggeom munhwa-ui baljeon-gwa seonggyeok” (Development and Characteristics of Slender Bronze Dagger Culture in North Korea). Hanguk sanggosa hakbo (Journal of Early Korean History) 47: 59–87.

14.

Jo, Jong-man. 1908. Chodeung daehan yeoksa (Elementary Korean History). Seoul: Hanyang seogwan.

15.

Jung, In-seung. 2013. “Wiman Joseon-ui cheolgi munhwa” (Iron Culture of Wiman Joseon). Baeksan hakbo (Journal of the Paeksan Society) 96: 39–77.

16.

Kim, Han-kyu. 1980. “Wiman Joseon gwangye junggukcheuk saryo-e daehan jaegeomto” (Reexamination of Chinese Historical Records on Wiman Joseon). Collection of Papers of Busan Women’s College 8: 14–23.

17.

Kim, Jong Il. 2004. Review of State Formation in Korea: Historical and Archaeological Perspectives, by Gina L. Barnes. Journal of Inner and East Asian Studies 1.1: 179 –185.

18.

Kim, Won-yong. 1987. Hanguk gogohak yeongu (Study of Korean Archeology). Seoul: Iljisa.

19.

Korean Archeological Society, ed. 2011. Hanguk gogohak gangui (Introduction to Korea Archeology). Seoul: Sahoi pyeongnon.

20.

Kwon, O-jung. 1992. Nangnanggun yeongu (A Study of Lelang Commandery). Seoul: Ilchokak.

21.

Lee, Chung-gyu. 2014. “Yodong seobukhan-ui chogi cheolgi munhwa-wa Wiman Joseon” (Early Iron Culture in Liaodong and Northwestern Korea and Wiman Joseon). Dongbuga yeoksa nonchong (Journal of Northeast Asian History) 44: 95–147.

22.

Mikami, Tsugio. 1961. Man-Sen genshi funbo no kenkyu (A Study of the Prehistoric Tombs of Manchuria and Joseon). Tokyo: Yoshikawa kobunkan.

23.

Mikami, Tsugio. 1966. Tohoku Ajia shi kenkyu (A Study of Ancient Northeast Asia). Tokyo: Yoshikawa kobunkan.

24.

National Museum of Korea. 1992. Hanguk-ui cheongdonggi munhwa (Bronze Culture of Korea). Seoul: Beomusa.

25.

Noh, Tae-don. 1999. “Wiman Joseon-ui jeongchi gujo” (Political Structure of Wiman Joseon). Sanun sahak (Sanun Historical Studies) 8: 187–208.

26.

Oh, Youngchan. 2006. Nangnanggun yeongu (Study of Lelang Commandery). Paju: Sakyejeol.

27.

Oh, Youngchan. 2014. “Nangnanggun yeongu-wa singminjuui” (Study of Lelang Commandery and Colonialism). Hanguk godaesa yeongu-ui sigak-gwa bangbeop (Research Perspectives and Methods of Korean Ancient Historiography), Noh Tae-don gyosu jeongnyeon ginyeom nonchong ganhaeng wiwonhoe, ed., 343–365. Paju: Sagyejeol.

28.

Oh, Youngchan, and Mark E. Byington. 2013. “Scholarly Studies on the Han Commanderies in Korea.” The Han Commanderies in Early Korean History, edited by Mark E. Byington, 11–47. Cambridge: Korea Institute, Harvard University.

29.

Pai, Hyung Il. 2000. Construction of “Korean” Origins: A Critical Review of Archaeology, Historiography, and Racial Myth in Korean State-Formation Theories. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

30.

Park, Dae Jae. 2004. Review of Construction “Korean” Origins: A Critical Review of Archaeology, Historiography, and Racial Myth in Korean State-Formation Theories, by Hyung Il Pai. Journal of Inner and East Asian Studies 1: 167–172.

31.

Park, Jun-hyoung. 2014. “Wiman Joseon-ui yeongyeok-gwa ingu” (Territory and Population of Wiman Joseon). Baeksan hakbo (Journal of the Paeksan Society) 99: 109–143.

32.

Park, Sun-mi. 2006. “Gojoseon-ui gangyeok-gwa jungsimji” (Territory and Capital of Gojoseon). Gojoseonsa yeongu 100-yeon (A Century of Research on Gojoseon History), edited by Gojoseonsa yeonguhoe and Northeast Asian History Foundation, 76–96. Seoul: Hakyoun Cultural Publishing.

33.

Park, Sun-mi. 2013. “Gogohak jaryo-ro bon Wiman Joseon-ui munhwa seonggyeok” (Cultural Characteristics of Wiman Joseon Based on the Archeological Materials). Dongyanghak (Oriental Studies) 53: 247–276.

34.

Peattie, Mark R. 1996. Shokuminchi: teikoku gozunen no koubou 植民地: 帝國50年の興 亡 (Japanese Colonial Empire: The Vicissitudes of Its Fifty-Year History). Translated by Asano Toyomi. Tokyo: Yomiuri shimbun.

35.

Sekino, Tadashi. 1932. Chosen bijutsushi (History of Korean Art). Keijo: Chosen shigakkai (Society of Korean History).

36.

Shim, Jae-hoon. 2002. “A New Understanding of Kija Choson as a Historical Anachronism.” Journal of Asian Studies 56.1: 271–305.

37.

Shiratori, Kurakichi. 1907. “Kankoku no kensetsu 韓 の建設” (Build up Korea). Eizan Koenshu (Collection of Eizan Lecture Notes), edited by Koike Nobuyosi, 816–837. Osaka: Osaka mainichi shimbun.

38.

Song, Ho-jeong. 2002. “Wiman Joseon-ui jeongchi cheje-wa samguk chogi bucheje” (Political System of Wiman Joseon and the Bu-System of the Early Three Kingdoms Period). Guksagwan nonchong (Collection of Papers on Korean History) 98: 1–25.

39.

Tamura, Koichi. 2001. Rakuro to Kookuri no kokogaku (Archeology of Lelang and Goguryeo). Tokyo: Doseisha.

40.

Won, Yeong-ui., and Yu Geun. 1906. Sinjeong dongguk yeoksa (New History of Korea). Seoul: Hwimun uisuk.

41.

Yi, Byeong-do. 1976 [1956]. “Wissi Joseon heungmak go” (Review of Wiman Joseon’s Rise and Fall). Hanguk godaesa yeongu (Study of Ancient Korean History), edited by Yi Byeong-do, 65–94. Seoul: Bakyeongsa.

42.

Yi, Mahn-yol. 1985. “Sipgu seigimal ilbon-ui hanguksa yeongu” (Japan’s Research on Korean History in the Late nineteenth Century). Cheongil jeonjaeng-gwa han-il gwangye (First Sino-Japanese War and Japan-Korea Relations), edited by Hanguksa yeonguhoe, 79–134. Seoul: Ilchokak.

Korea Journal